Compare
FirstMate vs FishingBooker
FishingBooker is a marketplace that helps anglers find charters. It can bring you new customers. FirstMate helps you book them directly, keep your revenue and own the relationship.
Side by side
Based on publicly listed features, checked November 2026. Check current offerings.
Bookings & Payments
| Feature | FirstMate | FishingBooker |
|---|---|---|
| Your own booking page and widget | Yes | Marketplace listing |
| Commission on your bookings | None | Yes |
Your own booking page and widget
- FirstMate
- Yes
- FishingBooker
- Marketplace listing
Commission on your bookings
- FirstMate
- None
- FishingBooker
- Yes
Customers & CRM
| Feature | FirstMate | FishingBooker |
|---|---|---|
| Full customer contact details | Yes | Limited |
| Competitors shown next to you | Never | Yes |
Full customer contact details
- FirstMate
- Yes
- FishingBooker
- Limited
Competitors shown next to you
- FirstMate
- Never
- FishingBooker
- Yes
Trip Operations
| Feature | FirstMate | FishingBooker |
|---|---|---|
| Waivers, crew assignment, catch logs | Yes | Not built in |
Waivers, crew assignment, catch logs
- FirstMate
- Yes
- FishingBooker
- Not built in
Marketing & Growth
| Feature | FirstMate | FishingBooker |
|---|---|---|
| Emails, contests and review replies | Yes | Not built in |
Emails, contests and review replies
- FirstMate
- Yes
- FishingBooker
- Not built in
Crew & Team
| Feature | FirstMate | FishingBooker |
|---|---|---|
| Tips, pay, hiring and Trip Help | Yes | Not built in |
Tips, pay, hiring and Trip Help
- FirstMate
- Yes
- FishingBooker
- Not built in
Analytics & Money
| Feature | FirstMate | FishingBooker |
|---|---|---|
| P&L and trip profitability | Yes | Not built in |
P&L and trip profitability
- FirstMate
- Yes
- FishingBooker
- Not built in
How you pay
FirstMate
$0 to $299 a month. Booking fee of 1.5% down to 0.75% by plan, added at customer checkout.
FishingBooker
Commission on each booking, commonly in the 15 to 20%+ range. Typical published pricing, check current rates. (checked November 2026)
When FishingBooker might fit you
Honest answer: FirstMate isn't for everyone.
- You're brand new and need a marketplace to be found at first.
- You're happy paying commission in exchange for leads. Many captains use both: a marketplace for discovery, FirstMate for repeat and direct bookings.
Switching is simple
Start free, send your export or calendar link, add the booking button to your site, and run both until you're ready.
How switching worksStart on $0 a month. No credit card.
We'll help you move over. Run it alongside what you use today.
No credit card · No contract